My letter to the Sunday Times forum page has been published. Not in its entirety though – the sarcastic bits were toned down – but the message has remained intact. Kudos to the editors for a good job.
Ashiq Idris has also responded to my e-mail. His reply below:
From: Ashiq Idris <firstname.lastname@example.org> Date: February 6, 2009 11:37:30 AM GMT+08:00 To: Laremy Lee Subject: Response to your Email Reply-To: email@example.com
I am writing to you in response to your email to the Association dated 2 Feb 2009. Here I would like to clarify on behalf of the Association that the Association had commissioned an independent Panel of Inquiry to look into the case. Upon completing their inquiry they have submitted their report to the Association which includes their recommendation on the punishment to be imposed. The TAS Management Committee agreed to adopt the recommendation and subsequently the two athletes were notified on the decision.
I would also like to clarify that the infringement was “Disobeying instruction of the coach” and the punishment given was imposed on the said infringement. Disobeying instruction is something the Association see very seriously and for that matter most other National Sports Associations.
I hope I have clarify the reason why they were being punished in contrary to what had been reported in the local media and speculated out of proportion.
I would like to thank you for your comments.
Is the case closed? I don’t know, but I still remain firm on my stand: although rules must be followed, this ‘rule’ in particular is archaic and has no place in our day and age. Also, some points to be clarified:
This isn’t about sex, or indecency, by the way, although many people have mistaken it to be so. Please do not be misled. It’s about jurisprudence, I think, but please let me know if I am using the term wrongly.
The media did not blow the matter out of proportion. The Straits Times merely reported on the truth, and they did a good job, might I add. The only thing that has been blown out of proportion is the nature and the severity of the punishment – if one is needed at all.
I think the above two points merely go to show that Singaporeans need a very good grounding in media literacy, and I’m glad the education system is making an attempt to bridge this gap.
In any case, I hope Dinah and Ying Ren keep on training. It would be nice to see them on the global stage someday, because these are two Singaporeans I’d be very proud to support and cheer my lungs out for.